Salt Water Pool vs Chlorine Pool: Which is More Practical?

LayorCare Blogger • June 11, 2019

Salt water pool vs chlorine pool: what's the difference in terms of maintenance, cost and practicality? Find out here

salt water pool vs chlorine pool

Did you know that 10.4 million households in the US have pools in their backyards? Are you thinking of joining them?

If you're considering installing a pool, you will have some choices to make, like whether you want a saltwater pool vs. a chlorine pool. To learn the differences in terms of maintenance, cost, and practicality, keep reading. We'll break it all down for you.

Saltwater Pool vs. Chlorine Pool

When deciding between a salt water pool vs chlorine pool, there is no right or wrong answer. You have to consider your budget and how much time you are willing to dedicate to the pool.

Once you have those answers, the right choice may seem a little more obvious.

Saltwater Pool

Saltwater pools do still have chlorine in them, however, the amount of chlorine that they have is much lower than a regular chlorine pool.

Another difference is that the chlorine in a saltwater pool isn't added by you or a pool maintenance person. The salt generator actually makes the chlorine through a process called electrolysis.

The lower chlorine levels in the pool will actually help out your skin and not dry it out as much.

Pros

There are some benefits to installing a pool with a saltwater generator.

Generally, these pools require less maintenance than a chlorine pool. As we said above, it will also be better for your skin because of the lower chlorine levels.

When you get out of the pool, you also won't have as difficult of a time getting rid of the smell of chlorine.

If you are planning on keeping your pool for a long time, then this may be a better bargain for your budget. The saltwater generator may cost a lot when you first buy it, but it will save you money in the long run because it's cheaper than buying the chemicals to put in the pool.

Saltwater pools are also generally the cleaner of the two. Having a salt water pool could also be safer than having a chlorine pool. That's because, with a salt water pool, you don't have to store all the harmful chemicals that are needed with a chlorine pool.

Cons

However, there are some disadvantages to owning a saltwater pool. If you aren't planning on keeping the pool for a long time, this may not be the best decision budget-wise.

The generator does cost a lot of money, and you will also have higher utility costs from having the generator running for a good portion of the day.

While there is less chlorine, there is more salt, and the salt can start to erode part of your pool, like the lights for example. You can avoid these issues by putting in lights made for saltwater pools.

If the salt water gets on your patio, it can also damage the tile. That is why it's important to have a sealant if you are going to install a saltwater pool.

Finally, saltwater pools can be more difficult and harder to manage, so you will most likely have to hire a professional to fix it if something goes wrong.

Chlorine Pool

Chlorine pools are more traditional and are also cheaper than most saltwater pools. However, they can be more difficult to maintain over time.

Because there is no generator making chlorine, you will need to add chlorine into the pool on your own. You will also need to make sure that the pH level is correct so that it can keep your pool clean.

You could always hire someone to take care of this part of the pool for you, but if you don't, you will need to keep the chemicals for the pool somewhere nearby.

While the chlorine levels will be higher than the saltwater pool, these are also the cheaper option. If you aren't going to have the pool for very long, this might be your best bet.

Pros

Chlorine pools do have their advantages. They are cheaper, especially in the beginning. While they are cheaper because you don't have to pay for a generator, you also won't have to pay the utilities for a running generator.

Saving money may be one of the biggest motivators for getting a chlorine pool.

Having a chlorine pool is also the easiest way to disinfect the pool water. Chlorine is great at killing bacteria and other harmful things in the water, and if your pool looks dirty, you can just add some chlorine into it.

Chlorine pools are also easier to fix if something goes wrong. They've been around for a while, and most pool companies will know how to fix them or maintain them.

You won't have to install anything extra or special into your pool either because there will be no salt water to corrode or destroy the equipment.

Cons

Some of the disadvantages of a chlorine pool are that they can be more damaging and harmful to the swimmers' skin and eyes. There are higher chlorine levels in a chlorine pool than salt water, and this can dry out skin faster and irritate eyes.

You will also have to dedicate a lot of time and energy to maintaining a chlorine pool. Because there is no generator to automatically put chlorine in the water, you will need to add it yourself. That means you will have to keep constant track of what the chlorine levels are.

If this is too much work for you, you can always hire a pool company.

Plan Your Own Pool Today

It can be difficult to decide between a salt water pool vs chlorine pool.

The decision ultimately comes down to how much money and time you are willing to dedicate to the pool.

If you have questions about which pool you should install, don't hesitate to contact us.

Pool maintenance tips
By LayorCare Blogger February 20, 2025
Discover expert tips on efficient pool care to save time and money. Learn how to balance chemicals, clean effectively, maintain filters, and use cost-saving heating options. Keep your pool sparkling with LayorCare Pool & Patio Protection's top-quality solutions
Shingle Roof Sealer
By LayorCare Blogger February 10, 2025
Protect your home with a durable shingle roof sealer to prevent leaks and damage. Roof sealants shield against moisture, UV rays, and harsh weather, extending roof lifespan and boosting energy efficiency. Learn how they work, their benefits, and the best application methods.
choosing the right sealant for pool tiles
By LayorCare Blogger January 31, 2025
Learn how to apply pool tile sealers to protect your tiles from water damage, stains, and chlorine. This guide covers choosing the right sealer, step-by-step application, and maintenance tips for a lasting, beautiful pool. LayorCare offers expert services for pool care.
Pool care tips
By LayorCare Blogger January 23, 2025
Discover essential pool care tips to keep your pool sparkling clean and safe. From skimming and scrubbing to balancing chemicals, maintaining equipment, and ensuring safety, learn how to create an inviting swimming environment year-round.
best Pool Maintenance tips
By LayorCare Blogger January 10, 2025
Discover simple and effective pool maintenance tips in this guide. Learn to maintain your pool’s structure, balance water chemistry, clean equipment, and tackle issues like cloudy water or algae. Ensure a safe, pristine swimming experience with expert advice and premium LayorCare products.
How to choose a pool cleaner
By LayorCare Blogger January 3, 2025
With our comprehensive guide, discover how to choose the best pool cleaner for your swimming pool. Explore manual, automatic, suction-side, pressure-side, and robotic cleaners to find the perfect match for your pool size, shape, and maintenance needs.
UV protection for roofs
By LayorCare Blogger December 25, 2024
Protect your roof with shingle sealers! Enhance durability, energy efficiency, and guard against UV rays, rain, and wind. Whether DIY or professional, sealers save you money and extend your roof's life.
Professional cleaners for pool tiles
By LayorCare Blogger December 10, 2024
Learn how professional cleaners and sealers keep pool tiles and patio pavers fresh, safe, and durable with expert maintenance and sealing tips.
Pool maintenance steps
By LayorCare Blogger November 23, 2024
Discover a simple weekly pool care routine to keep your pool sparkling and healthy. Learn step-by-step maintenance tips, from skimming debris to balancing water chemistry, ensuring safe and inviting swimming all season.
Pool cleaning mistakes
By LayorCare Blogger November 8, 2024
Avoid common pool cleaning mistakes to maintain high water quality. This guide covers essential upkeep like balancing chemicals, cleaning filters, and seasonal tips to keep your pool safe, clean, and inviting year-round.
Show More
Share by: